استكشاف الملاحظات الرسمية للحوار

Title: Breastfeeding as a ‘Resilient’ Food Security System: Celebrating…. And Problematizing Women’s Resilience in the face of chronic deprivation as well as emergencies. I will briefly touch upon as case studies - 1. breastfeeding and malnutrition, and 2. breastfeeding in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic. The discussion highlighted how to date women perform 76.2% of the total amount of unpaid care work, 3.2 times more time than men” (ILO). Still, only 40% reported substantial changes in outstanding care work in the first three months after childbirth. Childcare took up the bulk ... قراءة المزيدof women’s time, especially as they either took care of a child directly or remained responsible for a child over an average of 13.48 hours a day across the four countries 31 per cent reported giving up childcare to be able to engage in paid work. Several issues and concerns were shared, including but not limited to the medicalisation of a predominantly socio-economic problem with no recognition of community food systems such as breastfeeding and childcare as a possible intervention: thus, no investment, the Failure to recognise breastmilk as a critical source of protein and ‘count’ it in the treatment of SAM and the Failure to recognise breastfeeding as a health system in the prevention of childhood illnesses and mortality. Also, the attempts to introduce stand-alone magic bullet solutions of RUTF that often displace breast milk and, at the minimum, reinforce the ‘superiority’ of packaged foods over community-based products and may cause metabolic problems. Key recommendations were discussed and presented, including a universal implementation of the Maternity Protection [Convention, 2000 (No. 183)], a universally available childcare services and Child budgeting alongside gender budgeting with significant enhancements to both The key messages from the topic are as follows: 1. Breastfeeding is a resilient food system provided the facts below are taken into consideration: 2. Breastfeeding resilience relies entirely upon the status of time, energy, health, nutrition and general availability of women that are already chronically disenfranchised. 3. Maintaining the resilience of this food system demands a transformative structural and systemic shift to community-based solutions that are adequately قراءة القليل

Breastfeeding economics and lost milk The world's food system is failing us and especially our children. It is failing to deliver on human rights. It is failing to deliver for the planet's ecological systems. An important reason is that global systems for measuring the food system and the economy reflect misguided and outdated principles about important and economically valuable. This is unfair and harmful to women and children, and planetary health. This presentation focussed on the international system, which governs economic measurement and sets rules for defining GDP. This system decides w... قراءة المزيدhat is seen as economically valuable and prioritised by governments and international agencies. This system also shapes incentives and influences what is rewarded and profitable and what is not. It first outlined the basics of breastfeeding economics. Human beings are mammals. Milk helps build the highly adaptive immune system of human babies. It is the first vaccination against the disease. Breastfeeding and human milk are uniquely suitable for humans. When women and children cannot breastfeed sufficiently, for example, due to inadequate maternity entitlements, there are profound effects on human health and cognition and food security and nutrition. There are also costs on the environment and for animal welfare. These costs are not fully accounted for in market prices, which encourages excessive production and the use of commercial milk formula. The second part of the presentation summarises the international rules on how economic growth and food production is measured. The United Nations' national accounting system has been in place since the 1950s and its key element, GDP, excludes non-monetary production of goods and services. It counts commercial milk formula production, but not breastmilk produced, so when breastfeeding increases, GDP declines. Because breastfeeding is not visible in these statistics, its enormous economic value is not seen, and societal and fiscal resources are less likely to be invested. These rules allow for human milk to be counted if it is large enough and if there is a market price that can be used to value it, but no action has been taken. Using historical data, it can be shown that the economic value of breastmilk is very large. When breastfeeding declines, the lost food production is significant for the food and economic system. Still, women's loss of this uniquely value milk production for infants and young children go unnoticed. This system of measurement and accounting for economic value should be challenged as discriminatory against women and unhelpful to achieving a healthy and sustainable food system. Money is the language of policymakers. Breastfeeding is archetypal of women's crucial economic contribution. Unless breastfeeding is made visible in these critical statistics, international agencies and regulatory systems will expand global corporations' turnover and profit instead of working for people. By perpetuating the current harmful system, international agencies lose trust and credibility. To achieve healthy and sustainable food systems, what and how we value economic productivity and 'the economy must change, and this should start with valuing - and investing resources in – breastfeeding. قراءة القليل

The topic help highlight the role of IBFAN and BPNI that free from commercial interests are protecting, promoting and supporting breastfeeding. IBFAN has been working on the protection of breastfeeding ever since 1979, growing from 6 individuals to groups 160 countries; central to its work is implementing the International Code of Marketing for Breastmilk Substitutes and conflicts of interests. www.ibfan.org BPNI is a South Asia regional coordinating office and has been working in India since 1991 on breastfeeding protection, promotion, and support. www.bpni.org World Breastfeeding Trends Init... قراءة المزيدiative( WBTi) is BPNI’s global initiative building a repository of policy and programmes worldwide. https://www.worldbreastfeedingtrends.org/ 2016 BPNI took the lead in the study of Carbon Footprints of formula feeding in 6 countries The discussion highlighted the various reasons breastfeeding is environmentally friendly, as it fulfils a child’s right to the highest attainable standard of health. Due to food and nutrition, food security during the first two years and almost guarantees child survival, healthy growth and development, makes sound ecological sense as a ‘Tree’ contributes to the sustainability of food systems. AND FORMULA IS EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE, UNHEALTHY, ULTRA_PROCESSED, NOT SUSTAINABLE. The IBFAN report shows that each kilogram (kg) of milk formula generated 4 kg of (carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent) greenhouse gas during production. Over 2.8 million Tonnes of CO2 are produced from the 0.72 million Tonnes of infant formula sold yearly in just six countries, equivalent to 6 billion miles of car travel. The water footprint of infant formula is also problemati, with average water footprint of whole cows milk bei 940 L/kg; this translates in one kilogram of milk given about 200 g of milk powder, the water footprint of milk powder alone ~4700 L/kg. IBFAN and BPNI launched in 2004. The World Breastfeeding Trends Initiative (WBTi) assists countries to assess the status of and benchmarking the progress in implementing the Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding in a standard way. It is based on the WHO’s tool for a national assessment of policy and programmes on infant and young child feeding. The WBTi assists countries to measure strengths and weaknesses on the ten parameters of policy and programmes that protect, promote and support optimal infant and young child feeding (IYCF) practices. The WBTi also maintains a Global Data Repository of these policies and programmes. The unique web tool helps in colour-coding and scoring each indicator. The WBTi process stimulates local action, bringing people together and encourages collaboration and networking amongst critical organisations such as government departments, UN, health professionals, academics, civil society and other players (without conflicts of Interest). It assists in consensus building. Through use of the WBTi tool, countries work towards producing a “report card” and “report” that can be used to mobilise action at the local level by defining the gaps and recommendations for change. The report shows the average score and colour coding for each indicator on policy and programmes on a scale of 1–10. Most indicators fall into the yellow category, except for ‘‘health and Nutrition Care Systems’’(Indicator 5), with a slightly higher score (blue) and ‘fant Feeding during Emergencies’with with a lower score (red). The combined score of the 10 WBTi indicators related to IYCF policies and programmes is measured on a scale of 1–100. The combined average score for 84 countries is 59.9. Almost half of the countries (39) scored between 30 The following were the key recommendations from the topic: 1. Count Breastfeeding as the First Food System 2. Talk more about environmental impact and link with environmental groups. 3. Funding is critical to increasing breastfeeding rates and controlling marketing of baby foods-ensure through a firm resolution at World Health Assembly ($5 per child born and additional funds for maternity protection) 4. Research on the environmental impact of formula feeding at the national level may help in advocacy. قراءة القليل

Title: Breastfeeding and the food systems transformation agenda: towards healthy and sustainable first-food systems 1. Many are now calling for transformative food systems change. However, breastfeeding is too often neglected in food systems thinking, dialogue and action. This is a crucial omission to address, given the mother-child breastfeeding dyad is a remarkably sustainable on-demand food production system, and arguably the world’s shortest food supply chain – one that delivers unparalleled nutrition, safety and food security for the child – on a global scale. 2. Today’s ‘first-... قراءة المزيدfood systems’ – defined as the food systems that provision food for infants and children aged 0-36 months – are currently unhealthy and unsustainable, given breastfeeding is too often displaced by formula and other commercial foods that are harmful to health and the environment. First-food environments, including health systems, retail environments and digital media, are strongly influenced by the aggressive marketing of the baby food industry. The governance of infant and young child feeding too often favours commercial lobby groups. 3. A systems approach can help us to identify the most powerful leverage points for transforming first-food systems for health and sustainability. This will not only require policy actions to universalise maternity protection, comprehensively regulate the marketing of commercial baby foods, and other actions to protect, promote and support breastfeeding. It will also demand re-thinking the core values and priorities of the system itself, and especially giving priority to the rights of mothers, children and the environment over the commercial freedoms of industry. قراءة القليل

The overall conclusion of the dialogue and that the necessary activities Include the overarching message all the breastfeeding Bonuses addressing WICKED problems Of the Food System and a demand that breastfeeding is recognised as a whole system of nutrition, as well as nurturing and care that cannot be substituted by a commercial ultra-processed food product. Transform system values to recognise the importance of women’s contribution and the environment, and address the time poverty of women 1. Firstly, we need to change the underlying values of the food system as well as on other systems, S... قراءة المزيدuch as health and employment, which have failed to value women and out of date patriarchal systems, which deplete women and the environment and exploit animals, and fail to value women’s work, and ensure all have sufficient time budgets to enjoy free time Hold governments, health professionals and systems, and companies accountable for failure to protect the breastfeeding food system. 2. Secondly, we need to find new ways to hold governments, health professionals and Health Systems, and companies accountable for failing to protect, promote and support breastfeeding or even recognise its value; we must do this through insisting by investing in and resourcing baby-friendly hospital initiative code compliance and enforcement, Code compliance should be like tobacco advertising, and we should remove obstacles in the Health System during COVID 19 and take urgent action to end breaches of the WHO Code through digital marketing. We need to organise and align our groups with no conflict of interest to make strong demands on duty bearers 3. There need to be stronger demands made and wider sharing in society responsibility for breastfeeding to a more extensive range of groups whilst also an invigorating and resourcing, renew grassroots action and sharing knowledge, and identify and create political champions for change such as for baby-friendly hospitals, code implementation, maternity entitlements, whilst using economic research to identify and raise awareness of the dollars given to industry against breastfeeding, as well as the costs of not breastfeeding. Women to be resourced adequately for their productive roles in the Food System. 4. Women are resilient but need to be resourced to have real ‘choices’ as consumers, workers, and citizens. They are not a ‘free or cheap resource and are depleted. This means that there need to be a universal basic income and maternity entitlements and adequate resourcing of their needs as producers of care and food for infants and young children Get industry out of government 5. The power of industry in international and government policymaking must be ended, especially in breastfeeding, because the companies want to shape the tastes of young consumers from birth towards junk food, making them a consumer for life. Nowhere is this more evident than in Codex Alimentarius, and the use of Codex standards to make unnecessary products (like follow up and growing milks) marketable must stop. Governments are for citizens but have become agents of corporations trying to hold down prices/wages of small producers and women workers to increase profits rather than improve People’s nutrition and food security and the environment in which they live their lives. Baby food marketing to policymakers is part of industry influence that must end, including via UN agencies partnering with food and pharma companies. Level the marketing playing field for breastfeeding by stopping baby food marketing at every level Stop the marketing power of industry by enforcing compliance with strong regulation of baby food marketing and by fully funding citizens groups to deliver comprehensive grassroots marketing and promotion of breastfeeding as the first food system to develop, restore and protect breastfeeding cultures and enabling environments. The industry has immense power to shape social culture and undermine breastfeeding, and there is an urgent need to stop their influence of messaging in harmful ways to breastfeeding. Also, we need to reclaim the language and stop the marketing through regulation and through قراءة القليل

Breastfeeding is the foundation of sustainable food systems. Yet, it is virtually ignored in food systems discourse. Consequently, infants and young children are effectively excluded from food systems thinking and action. This UNFSSD aimed to explore how to ensure the acknowledgement of breastfeeding as the original and universal first food system. It aimed to increase awareness and understanding of the role of breastfeeding as the most sustainable, localised and normative food system for delivering food security and nutrition to infants and young children. The Dialogue convened diverse groups... قراءة المزيد to share transformative ideas, build alliances and align efforts to protect, promote and support breastfeeding across the 5 UNFSS Action Tracks, and to identify the most promising levers for generating systems-wide change. The guiding principle was the right to breastfeed for infants and young children and breastfeeding women. The first speaker, Dr Phil Baker, described the mother-child breastfeeding dyad as a sustainable on-demand food production system and the world's shortest food supply chain, which delivers unparalleled nutrition, safety and food security for children globally. Yet today's 'first-food systems' –that provide food for infants and children aged 0-36 months – are unhealthy and unsustainable because breastfeeding is often displaced by formula and commercial foods that are harmful to health and the environment. First-food environments, including health systems, retail environments, digital media, and governance, are subject to the baby food industry's predatory marketing and aggressive influence. A systems approach can identify leverage points for transforming first-food systems for health and sustainability. This will require policy actions to universalise maternity protection, regulate the marketing of commercial baby foods, and protect, promote and support breastfeeding. It will also demand re-thinking the core values and priorities of the system to prioritise the rights of mothers, children and the environment over the commercial freedoms of industry. Dr Arun Gupta discussed the silence on the risks of formula feeding, both for infants and women's health and for the environment. Measured in terms of fuel, water and resources used and the waste products created through production, transport and use, the formula is a disaster, not only for human health but for the environment too. By contrast, breastfeeding protects the health and the environment. Dr Gupta looked at policies and programmes that support breastfeeding and made recommendations for research, policy and advocacy. Dr Julie Smith discussed breastfeeding economics and how they should be used to make breastfeeding visible and valued. She described how the international rules for measuring GDP include the production of all food commodities, except breastmilk and home-produced foods. Yet, the rules allow for the inclusion of these products, which make sizeable contributions to food systems. Breastmilk is a valuable food commodity and should be counted in food statistics and the calculation of GDP. Conversely, the value of breastmilk not produced ("lost milk") should also be calculated. The current practice of excluding breastmilk means the substantial importance of breastfeeding is invisible and biases economic decisions and policymaking against women and children. قراءة القليل

Consumer responsibility: Although there was agreement on the need to change consumer behaviour, there was some extent of disagreement on the share of responsibility that should be borne by consumers. Some guests insisted that responsibility should not only be put on their shoulders but also on governments’ → can have a role to play in constraining food choices/big companies and in informing them, notably through regulating food marketing (e.g. banning greenwashing). Others highlighted that too little responsibilisation hinders change. Vertical farming: An asset or not? 1) Benefits: Accordi... قراءة المزيدng to one of our guests personally involved in a vertical farming initiative - Can tackle restricted access to land - Enables land use savings and water savings - Control of the environment that happens in indoor farms seems especially promising In the face of climate change - According to a study from Wageningen University and Delft University technology (both in the Netherlands), production in vertical farms could reduce CO2 use by 67% (UAE) to 92% (NLD) compared with greenhouses. This figure is even higher for open field farming - Will become less expensive with economies of scale → finance should be unlocked to incentivise investments (costs of entry are high) 2) Critiques (put forward by other guests) - Which criteria was this study based on? - Remains expensive and energy-intensive. Economies of scale could occur in the next 5-10 years, making it affordable and less energy-intensive. - What about poorer countries that cannot invest in the technologies, etc. Relevance of discussing this at European level given geographic discrepancies questioned: Engagement of consumers varies, support of government too. Ambiguity between the need to raise the value of food to e.g. decrease food waste, and social equity. قراءة القليل

Does not apply to us as we did not have any breakout rooms, the whole discussion was conducted with the whole group.

1) Environmental and economic sustainability Need to involve all stakeholders, including civil society and consumers to achieve systemic changes. There is sometimes a trade-off between supplying local and sustainable goods: for a given cooperative, there is a dilemma between their desire to sell local and sustainable products only (while being aware that their customers will buy non-local, unsustainable products in supermarkets anyways), or propose sustainable products that are not local (also because sometimes a specific good is not produced locally following sustainable practices). Focus on ... قراءة المزيدconsumers to change the supply chain. - As they currently lack knowledge about hidden costs of the supply chains, their empowerment is needed by informing them, notably through clear labelling of the products’ economic and environmental quality. - Re-giving food the importance it should have in our lives, enhancing public consciousness of its value → could reduce food waste and increase time/efforts/share of income dedicated to it. - A problem is that buying power remains the most important criterion (food security) for consumers. Financial tools could help internalise externalities in food production and guide citizens towards more sustainably produced food - Idea of differentiated VAT depending on product (e.g. taxing fruits/vegetables at 0%, meat at highest level) - Carbon pricing of food - Withdrawal/reduction of subsidies for ‘unsustainable agriculture’ (e.g. beef) -“Social security of food”: e.g. give an allocation to families that wouldn’t have enough resources to purchase sustainable food. - But: issue of the weight of lobbies Question of socio-economic fairness along the chain: a few retailers capture a lot of economic value at the expense of the many farmers 2) Upscaling local solutions More participatory democracy can mobilize actors around the transition towards more sustainable food systems, to get them thinking about it and engage them. - Foster the idea of a food policy, which already exists at local level, at European level. → Idea of a European food policy committee as a discussion platform involving all stakeholders: policy-makers, scientists, etc. - At a more local level, rural parliaments could be established as platforms/a space where rural people could express their opinions, to enhance cooperation between rural and urban areas. - Creations of hubs where farmers and consumers could meet. Cities: - Role of medium-size cities in connecting rural and urban areas - Role of eurocities to be the intermediate between smaller cities and European institutions Urban agriculture (e.g. viverein, Rome): Way to educate people about what it involves to grow food, the work it represents, and so the value of food more broadly. Moreover, it can also be a catalyser for change as it shows citizens how the system can be changed. We identified problematics resulting from the EU policy framework: - it can prevent sustainable public procurement (public school canteens) under competition law. There is no possibility to discriminate for local and sustainable food. - Also, European subsidies favour unsustainable agriculture (eg. for beef farming and milk, creating a huge food surplus due to subsidies). These subsidies for unsustainable agriculture should be discontinued or at least decreased. There is a need instead for Institutional support of cooperatives that are growing local and sustainable food. 3) Youth engagement in short supply chains We underlined the importance of sensibilisation of the work of farmers to young people: give new signals, that farmers have actually a social utility, to enhance interest in their work. Supporting connections between young farmers and more experienced farmers so that they can learn from each other. Creating new job opportunities to bring back people to rural areas is important. Educative projects needed from a young age to popularise projects like CSA and food coops among youth. Underlining the obstacles from conservative governments preventing young people to voice their interests. More generally, seeing youth not as protesters but as stakeholders would be a first step. Following the example of some European institutions and the local authorities of different cities, youth could be given an institutionalised way to bring its opinion to politicians. قراءة القليل

The dialogue tackled the ways to and problems identified to shorten Food Systems supply chains in Europe. This can be related to every Action Tracks, but more specifically with the first, second and fifth ones (Shift to sustainable consumption patterns and Build resilience to vulnerabilities, shocks and stress). Our three main focuses during the dialogue were: 1° The environmental and economic sustainability of SFSC. The following sub- topics were discussed in detail here: a) Challenges faced when trying to grow local food in ways that limit harm to the environment while trying to be economic... قراءة المزيدally sustainable at the same time. b) Food affordability challenges and potential ways to ensure food remains affordable to everyone, including low-income citizen groups and vulnerable groups of people. 2° Upscaling local solutions of SFSC. The following sub-topics were discussed in detail here: a) Barriers to scaling up to achieve systemic change, and ways to improve upscaling. b) Types of policies (i.e. EU/regional/city level etc.) needed to support upscaling. c) Local solutions as a way to build resilience to vulnerabilities and shocks. 3° Encouraging youth engagement in SFSC. The following sub-topics were discussed in detail here: a) The role of youth and how to include youth in food supply chains. b) Ways youth can support in realising the benefits of short supply chains. قراءة القليل

Strengths and vulnerabilities within food systems Many were of the view that the vulnerabilities in food systems is due to bad governance whereas others also stated otherwise it is due to non-existent policies of what actually a food systems is Areas that need further exploration More participants had the notion that Food Systems was all about food. With experts in the dialogue, they were able to grasp few understanding of the general scope of food systems. This means more explorations and capacity building needs to be done to further educate and highlight the importance of a robust food syste... قراءة المزيدms to productivity and efficiency Practices that are needed for food systems sustainability. Some of the submitted different answers were good governance, youth inclusion, realistic policies, technology and education. Stakeholders whose interests should be prioritized According to some participants, Youth must be the first prioritized whiles others made cases for Farmers as the first to be considered as without farmers, no food production. قراءة القليل

Topic 1: Networking and digital engagement Below are some of the key issues highlighted by the farmers and proposed solutions, priority action areas, and policy recommendations. Challenges highlighted: a) Capacity gap among farmers runing agribusiness b) Young people scattered in several digital platforms instead of a one-stop-shop. c) Gender digital gap and information asymmetry d) Farmers face difficulties in getting organized to have access to information about agricultural policies, funding sources, and legal regulations. Identified priority action areas for farmers inclusion in networking... قراءة المزيد and digital engagement: a) Peer-to-peer learning is a key solution to close the capacity gap among the farmers. Digital platforms that encourage such activities are central to ensuring more farmers have access to information that directly contributes to the growth of their businesses. Also, a well-encompassing platform that builds alliances among many organizations that work with farmers people to initiate collective action was found necessary. b) Encourage platforms to act as a broker between the fermers and finance service providers will address the need for farmers tailored financial support. c) Create stronger farmer associations to be able to keep governments accountable, become aware of current legislation to influence policies and regulations. قراءة القليل

There is a big capacity gap when getting into agriculture, especially across different value chain touchpoints and more importantly knowledge on policy. One of the actions stakeholders will take together is to deepen their engagement efforts with the farmers to ensure access to information about agricultural policies financial agencies and legal regulations is further deepened. The importance of forming new alliances among many organizations that work with farmers people to raise farmers voices and initiate collective action was further stressed. Below are key priority action areas we identifi... قراءة المزيدed: a) Set up networking opportunities that accommodate farmer’s needs (e.g., the timing of meetings) and be accessible in networks and rural settings their existing social networks, Create stronger farmer associations to be able to keep governments accountable, become aware of current legislation to be able to influence policies and regulations. c) Organizations running Agripreneurship programs have dedicated calls for farmers. This perspective boosts farmer's participation in project calls/applications, therefore, giving priority to them. d) Increase knowledge access of existing policies, the art of policymaking, and advocacy through translation to local languages. قراءة القليل

The focus of the Dialogue was on: (i) environmental and economic shocks on African Food Systems caused by global pandemic (ii) examining gaps and functionalities of African Food Systems. (iii) access to funding for farmers and innovative ideas. (iiii) opportunities in the food industry. The focus of the dialogue was to create dedicated venues for farmers, particularly rural people have their say, collectively set their agenda, and suggest their pathway towards more equitable and farmers-friendly food systems. The dialogue adopted a gender and inclusivity lens to address the specific needs and ... قراءة المزيدpriorities of rural farmers. The dialogue achieved the following outcomes: 1. Community: Young Agrienterpreneurs, rural farmers networks, and farmers-serving organizations across Ghana were meaningfully engaged to share experiences, lessons learned, and solutions for youth farmers inclusion in agri-food systems. 2. Advocacy: Voices of farmers rural women and men raised, and visibility given to their transformative role in agri-food systems. 3 farmers-led policy agenda: Recommendations and priority actions identified to strengthen farmers agency as changemakers and builders of resilient and sustainable agri-food systems, with a focus on inclusivity and gender equality. The identified promising solutions/priority action areas and policy recommendations were on the following topics: 1. Networking and digital engagement 2. Access to finance and business support services 3. Gender equality and inclusivity 4. Accountability and political participation. قراءة القليل

There were no major areas of divergence among participants.

Regulatory and Administrative (Policy): Through the group discussion in the regulators group, the engagement of government has been identified in 4 specific areas – 1. Field level engagement of the government by involving the sanitary inspectors 2. If government can facilitate some investment on the infrastructure facilities 3. The school meals that are present in the government schools can include these smart snacks item in the existing menu 4. The traditional snacks can be prepared in a better, healthier way with local government support. In the policy level, the regulations on the adolesc... قراءة المزيدent’s snacks must ensure that those processed/unprocessed foods are with less sugar and less salt. Dr. Rudaba Khondker, Country Director, Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN), pointed out about “How can we bring this in the policy makers’ platform to make sure that there is a standard solution to reduce the sugar and salt from the contents of the food that the adolescents are consuming, whereas they are processed or homemade.” It is also mentioned that the target group should include adolescents from both urban and rural area of Bangladesh. The smart snacks examples can be set in the government school level, and then to spread in the private schools too. Not alone government, but together with adolescents themselves, parents, school management and private sector to work together and establish this smart snack program. On regard to this Ms. Saiqa Siraj, Country Director, Nutrition International summarized as, “In participation of parents, school management, government subsidies and private sector, it will be a sustainable program, otherwise only through government funding, providing midday meals to this huge number of schools will not be possible.” قراءة القليل

Food Entrepreneurs: As per the summary of the entrepreneurs’ discussion, a platform can be proposed where the nutritious snacks items can be listed ensuring good volume of customers, for better production and lesser cost. Ensuring good volume of customer of these smart snacks would lessen the cost and make it more affordable to everyone. One of the food entrepreneurs named Ms. Mehnaz Rahman Lira said, “Now all the parents and adolescents are very concerned about the nutritional value of the food.” According to their discussion, delivery system and food nutrition value assessment organiza... قراءة المزيدtions should be connected with the platform to solve the delivery and nutrition value measurement challenges. قراءة القليل

Adolescents & Youth Representatives: The ideal snack item that came up after the group discussion of the adolescents was contained of these four must attributes – 1. Tasty 2. Eye-catchy 3. Affordable and 4. Nutritious. They also mentioned how the individual behavior change is needed to choose the nutritious snacks. They want more nutritious snacks options to be available in the market. Also, they think the traditional snacks like shingara, fuchka, can be made in a better and healthier way. For example, using good oil, maintaining hygiene, etc. Regarding this an adolescent named Meher Afr... قراءة المزيدoz Tisha from Viqarunnisa Noon School & College said, “For our dream snacks like Shingara, fuchka, if we can tell the shopkeepers or who are making these, to use good oil and vegetable in making these, then it should be healthier for us.” قراءة القليل

Primary objective of the dialogue was to build a strategic framework and hear from the key stakeholders to stimulate and support “Smart Snacks” as an inclusive business model. The secondary objective was to understand the adolescent perspectives (demand), also, challenges, scopes of regulatory support & incentivise, private sector engagement (supply) perspectives. The adolescent population in Bangladesh is almost one third of total population which is around 33 million, and a large portion of these adolescents are school going who used to avail street foods on regular basis. In recent ... قراءة المزيدdays, adolescents are tending to avail more street foods (Open and packaged) to meet their regular appetite when they need to eat something which are very much unhygienic, poor food quality (nutrition value) as well as unhealthy. These street foods are tasty and less expensive which lure adolescents to aim for those. Adolescents nutrition status is very critical in Bangladesh and need proper attention from all relevant stakeholders. An inclusive and sustainable business model engaging private sector to invest in adolescent friendly snacks may be introduced to offer as a commercial product. The government can facilitate support in the value chain to ensure the product is cost affordable for all the adolescents through different incentives & supports. These snack items will be manufactured under a standard guideline, quality and nutrient enriched for adolescents. As commercial product, these also has to be tasty, attractive in package and most importantly extensive communication i.e. advertisements. قراءة القليل

The dialogue started with the opening remarks by Dr. Rudaba Khondker, Country Director, GAIN. Mr. Mostafa Banna, Ministry of Food, shared his valuable remarks followed by Dr. Bulbul Islam, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. After the briefing and opening remarks, three categories of stakeholders were divided into three different breakout rooms as per below: Adolescents & Youth Representatives: This group of participants represented the demand side of the smart snacks. In this room the overall discussion took place focusing on the experience and expectation of the adolescents. The adole... قراءة المزيدscents talked about their daily snack intake practices, what is available out there, what they are attracted to, the amount they prefer to spend on snacks, etc. The discussion ended with individual description of their dream snack item. Food Entrepreneurs: The group of the food entrepreneurs represented the supply side of the smart snacks. Present scenario of the healthy snacks’ availability, demand of it from the adolescents have been discussed in detail in this room. Also, the challenges they are facing in order to produce it, and required necessary support needed for producing nutritious food for adolescents have been discussed thoroughly by them. Regulatory and Administrative (Policy): The participants at the room of regulatory and administrative discussed on what supportive and regulatory measures are to be taken to promote safe and nutritious food for adolescents. Also, the different ways to engage government from local levels. قراءة القليل