Independent Dialogue
Geographical focus:
No borders
Area of divergence
The dialogue prompted lively discussions, especially during the breakout sessions and in the chat. One area of debate that brought diverse perspectives was centered on the topic of financing the seaweed movement and industry integration in non-producing countries, many of which are in the Western hemisphere. All participants acknowledged that there is a need for ambitious action in bringing seaweed to the forefront of food systems as a game changing solution to issue areas like climate change, malnutrition, women and youth empowerment, and more. Yet there were differing views on where the fina
... Read morencing for the integration of scaled-up production of seaweed would come from and whether it should be allocated on the basis of issue area. For example, should seaweed be financed by global funds focused on climate finance and if so, what steps need to be taken to get to said point? Alternatively, is the best approach to decentralize financing and integrate the growing seaweed movement into the current industry, scaling up by getting more smallholder farmers introduced to seaweed and aquaculture? Some divergence also came around the topic of regulations and the role of the private sector versus governments in creating these regulations. Some participants felt that governments needed to play a strong role in creating safe regulatory environments to prevent unintended harm to ecosystems and consumers from lack of information. Others felt that the current state of regulations, particularly in Europe, were already too restrictive and not conducive to small scale producers being able to compete. They also felt a strict regulatory environment stifled innovation, and that a kinder environment, led by the private sector, would encourage increased innovations in seaweed usage and applications. There were mixed opinions when it came to integrating seaweed into diets globally. For example, some participants believed that although there are some paths to introducing seaweed to more regions that do not traditionally consume it, it will be difficult to change dietary norms on a large scale. Some felt that would be particularly challenging for Africa, despite its great potential, because it does not have the cultural or traditional background in seaweed farming or consumption to immediately become an industry leader. Another area of divergence revolved around food safety. Some felt toxicants that can be found in seaweed present a serious issue for human consumption. On the other hand, it was noted that although seaweed does absorb substances from the sea, so does everything else that we consume from the ocean, including fish and other sea vegetables. Most participants in these discussions agreed that further research was necessary to truly understand this dimension of seaweed. One group diverged in opinions on whether or not there were clear benefits for organic aquaculture and whether or not sustainability has to include organic. Views ranged from there being a need for certified organic and regenerative aquaculture to handling this issue via integrated multi-trophic aquaculture that doesn’t necessarily need to be harvested in the ocean nor organic. By the end of the discussion the group agreed that there are clear benefits to both, but whether or not seaweed’s form of sustainability should take on one or the other was left for further discussion. An unresolved divergence of views concerned whether or not to create a new international agency focused on seaweed. I. Most participants expressed that there is no need to form a new organization, rather to strengthen existing UN organizations, especially FAO, to better incorporate seaweed into its work, through its clear linkages to multiple SDGs. Others noted the need for building strong cooperatives or federations to provide the full range of value chain services to members, especially smallholders, and represent the voices of seaweed family farmers in governance. Read less
Action Track(s): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Keywords: Data & Evidence, Environment and Climate, Finance, Governance, Human rights, Innovation, Policy, Trade-offs, Women & Youth Empowerment